Recent News
April 29, 2025
Federal Judge Denies City of Philadelphia’s Motion to Dismiss Lawsuit Concerning Philadelphia’s Vehicle Towing Procedures

Kohn, Swift & Graf, P.C. is representing approximately thirty plaintiffs in Smith et al v. the City of Philadelphia, 22-cv-5092, a purported class action in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, challenging the City of Philadelphia’s so-called “courtesy towing” program.
On February 8, 2025, U.S. District Judge Mitchell S. Goldberg denied the City’s motion to dismiss the case.
The lawsuit alleges that the City has, for years, relocated vehicles without providing notice to vehicle owners and without any coherent system for tracking where the vehicles have been relocated. Plaintiffs allege that the City’s vehicle relocation program leads to lost, ticketed, and impounded vehicles, through no fault of the vehicle owners, and violates their Fourth Amendment possessory rights in relation to their vehicles and their Fourteenth Amendment due process rights.
This ruling allows the plaintiffs’ claims to proceed to discovery and is an important step in the effort to hold the City accountable for policies that have impacted thousands of residents.
To learn more about the case and its implications, watch this video by CBS Philadelphia.
Updates for this case will be posted on our website.
Contact a Kohn Swift Attorney
Because of the pandemic we may be working remotely, so please leave a message and we will return your call promptly.
Related News
See All NewsRobert A. Swift Represents Marcos Victims in Second Circuit Arelma Case Hearing
On March 11, 2025, Robert A. Swift, senior member of Kohn Swift & Graf, appeared before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit to represent a class of…
Read more
Kohn Swift Hosts Forum of International Human Rights Lawyers and Advocates
Robert Swift, senior member of Kohn Swift & Graf, hosted a forum on human rights with participants from fifteen countries including human rights lawyers, investigators, and NGO professionals in Philadelphia…
Read more
Three Kohn, Swift and Graf Attorneys Receive BEST LAWYERS© Recognition
The 2024 edition of Best Lawyers© recognizes three Kohn Swift & Graf attorneys: Joseph C. Kohn (antitrust) William E. Hoese (antitrust) Zahra R. Dean (Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch, Mass…
Read more